Liberté, Égalité, Rentrée!
Updated: Nov 1
An exasperated Parisian reflects on France's annual return to school, work, strikes, demonstrations, and the peculiar art of loving a country that occasionally drives her up the wall.

Ah, September! The Season of Discontent
There's something wonderfully reassuring about the French calendar. July and August are for escaping the city, lounging on beaches, lingering over rosé, and complaining about the tourists. September is for returning home, complaining about the government, and taking to the streets.
Welcome to la rentrée.
For the uninitiated, la rentrée is far more than the beginning of the school year. It's a national ritual, a collective psychological reset, and, apparently, an invitation to rediscover everything that's wrong with France.
Children return to their classrooms. Politicians return to their microphones. Trade unions dust off their banners. And somewhere in Paris, someone is already planning a demonstration.
By October, the whole affair starts to resemble a badly organized street festival, minus the music and with considerably more tear gas.
As for Madame Blogary? She's staying indoors, thank you very much. There's coffee in the kitchen, books beside her laptop, and absolutely no desire to discover whether the afternoon's entertainment involves overturned garbage bins, smashed shop windows, or another confrontation with the police.
A Love Affair with France, Complicated by the French
I love France. Its language, literature, architecture, philosophical traditions, cafés, extraordinary regional diversity, and stubborn insistence that life should involve more than work and the accumulation of material possessions.
I love that people can spend an entire evening debating the proper way to prepare a vinaigrette, comparing summer vacations, and planning their next escape, which, conveniently, is only a few school weeks away.
I even admire the French capacity for dissent.
After all, this is a country whose modern political identity was forged through revolution. Questioning authority is practically a national pastime, and there's something deeply admirable about a population unwilling to accept every government decision without rigorous scrutiny.
But must everything become a confrontation?
Must legitimate grievances so often spill onto the boulevards, accompanied by disruption, destruction, and occasionally outright violence?
And why, oh why, does it all seem to kick off just as everyone's returned from their summer holidays?
Perhaps the French national motto needs a seasonal amendment:
Liberté, Égalité ... et Manifestation à la Rentrée!
The Curious Case of the Annual French Uprising
France has a long and often admirable history of social movements. Workers' rights, paid holidays, and social protections didn't simply materialize because successive governments woke up feeling generous.
Protest has helped shape the country. But somewhere along the way, the distinction between protest as a democratic instrument and confrontation as a political reflex seems to have become blurred.
Peaceful demonstrations are one thing. Smashing shop windows, looting businesses, and destroying public property are quite another.
And the irony is almost painful. When public services are already struggling, how exactly does wrecking bus shelters or damaging infrastructure improve anyone's situation?
Who pays for the repairs? Who loses a day's earnings? Who cleans up the mess?
Usually, ordinary people. Including those whose interests the protesters claim to defend.
Of course, I understand the frustration. Rising living costs, economic insecurity, strained public services, and political disillusionment are real problems. But understanding anger doesn't mean applauding every way it's expressed.
And here's what really puzzles me: when did being against something become a political position in its own right?
Too often, the reaction seems to depend less on what's being proposed than on who's proposing it. A perfectly sensible idea can become unacceptable simply because it comes from the wrong politician, party, or government.
Whatever happened to examining the actual proposal? Weighing its merits, questioning its assumptions, considering the consequences, and perhaps even admitting that someone we fundamentally disagree with might occasionally have a good idea?
Being critical isn't the same as being contrary. And reflexively rejecting an idea doesn't make us independent thinkers any more than blindly accepting it does.
Perhaps the most rebellious thing we could do these days is stop choosing sides long enough to start thinking for ourselves.
What Must the Neighbors Think?
Perhaps my international upbringing makes me particularly sensitive to all this. Having grown up between countries, languages, and cultural traditions, I've never believed that loving a place requires defending everything its inhabitants do.
Quite the opposite. Sometimes a little distance makes national habits appear all the more peculiar. And watching Paris descend into another bout of unrest, I struggle to see how destruction celebrates the very freedoms of expression and assembly that France rightly holds dear.
France is one of the world's great cultural treasures. Its contributions to literature, philosophy, art, architecture, science, and political thought are immense. Its cities and landscapes attract visitors from across the globe.
Yet the images that occasionally make international headlines are of burning barricades, shattered windows, clouds of tear gas, and streets littered with debris.
What a dreadful advertisement for such a beautiful country.
And what about the economic consequences? France already has a reputation for relatively high corporate taxes, extensive labor protections, and complex regulations. Add recurring disruption and occasional violence to the picture, and I can't help wondering how many potential investors decide that setting up shop elsewhere might be rather less of a headache.
Metaphorically and literally.
Of course, dramatic footage makes for compelling television. Millions of people go about their ordinary lives without attracting a single camera crew, while a burning vehicle can make headlines around the world.
But reputations matter. So does the experience of actually living here.
There's something profoundly sad about watching a country you love become associated, however unfairly or disproportionately, with recurring scenes of disorder.
And something exceptionally irritating about the expectation that the rest of us should simply shrug our shoulders, pour another glass of wine, and accept the whole spectacle as just another charming expression of la vie française.
Cultural Identity Isn't a Loyalty Oath
Which brings me, rather unexpectedly, to cultural identity.
We tend to think of culture in terms of language, cuisine, literature, traditions, and charming local customs. But culture also shapes how we argue, how we respond to authority, and how readily we question our own assumptions.
The French pride themselves on their rebellious spirit. And rightly so, to a point. But when resistance becomes almost automatic, is it still an expression of independent thought? Or simply another form of conformity, dressed up as rebellion?
There's something wonderfully ironic about a nation that celebrates free thinking while sometimes appearing remarkably united in its determination to oppose whoever happens to be in charge.
After all, a bad idea doesn't become good because it comes from someone we admire. Nor does a good idea become bad because it comes from someone we dislike.
I can love France without loving every French habit. I can admire its revolutionary heritage without believing that every disagreement calls for another round of barricades. And I can defend the right to protest while questioning whether perpetual confrontation is the most constructive way forward.
Cultural identity, as I see it, isn't about unquestioningly embracing every national tradition or collective reflex. It's about understanding where those habits come from while remaining free to examine them.
And perhaps genuine independence of thought begins precisely there: with the willingness to question our own side as rigorously as we question the other.
Meanwhile, Madame Blogary is staying indoors, contemplating another cup of coffee and hoping that, one day, the French might become as enthusiastic about working together to find and implement solutions as they are about denouncing problems, pointing fingers, and finding scapegoats.
Vive la France. Mais, de grâce, laissez les poubelles tranquilles!
Madame Blogary
Paris, October 2026


Comments